Sunday, 8 December 2013

V Panopticism

What is the major effect of Panopticon?
The major effects of Panopticon is the automatic function of power.

How does the architecture [institution] create and sustain a power relation independent of the person who exercises it?
The architecture of institutions sustains power in the inmates by been observed, and they don’t know when they are been watched so they don’t know when they are needed to act that way or not.

Read from P66 2nd paragraph, in what way is the Panoptican efficient?
"The efficiency of power, its constraining force have, in a sense, passed over to the other side - to the side of it's surface of application" 

How does the Panopticism do the work of a natural [scientist]?
"It makes it possible to draw up differences, among patients, to observe the symptoms of each individual

In what ways was the Panopticon a laboratory?
"But the Panopticon was also a laboratory; it could be used a machine to carry out experiments, to alter behaviour, to train or correct individuals"

List the conditions in which Panopticism strengthens power?
‘it can reduce the number of those who exercise it, while increasing the number of those on whom it is exercised. Because it is possible to intervene at any moment and because the constant pressure acts even before the offences, mistakes or crimes have been committed. Because in these conditions its strength is that it never intervenes, it is exercised spontaneously and without noise, it constitutes a mechanism whose effects follow from one another. Because without any physical instrument other than architecture and geometry, it acts directly on individuals; it gives ‘power of mind over mind’.

According to Julius (1831) how is the panoptic principle particularly useful in a society made of private individuals and the state?
It is useful because many people can be observed but not in a way that would make them go mad.

Also according to Julius, rather than suppress the individual, what effect does the panoptic principle have?
'individual is carefully fabricated'


The Gaze




The Gaze is a clever method used in advertising, in this last photo the man has the power and he is looking towards us. The photo has quite an uncomfortable feeling about it because the woman’s gaze is on the man. The image looks like you are interrupting something, which works well for the name of the product ‘guilty’.

II Simulacra

I have created a few small summaries of the texts, which I have looked at about Plato ‘The Republic’, Jessica Evans, Stuart Hall ‘Visual Culture and Jean Baudrillard ‘Simulacra and Simulation’. I looked at what they are trying to get across and my thoughts on the texts.

In Plato The Republic it talks about a cave, where people are forced to watch a screen, what ever is shown on the screen the people see as the truth. A prisoner from the cave escaped and saw the real world, he saw people, things you can touch etc, by him talking to people and seeing different things his thinking developed. The cave is referring to belief and illusion and how people’s thoughts of reality are not the same as what reality actually is. The writing suggests that it is not certainty that reality exist beyond you; Plato believed that reality exists beyond us but not here. I think that it could be a metaphor of what society is actually like now, where you are almost forced to believe anything with all the adverts. When I thought about this text the whole thing reminded me of ‘Sims’ where people are controlling the characters making them do what they want them to do.

In the section of Jessica Evans, Stuart Hall ‘ visual culture’ it explains the different between both first and second world thinkers and the knowledge and understandings from each. The first world thinkers want to get back the original concept and meanings of images. Looking at what they originally meant and how they were firstly portrayed. However the second world thinkers want to allow images to have many different meaning and gain new meanings to become established in different ways. When images are been used over an over again and keep being repeated the context is flattened and looses it’s meaning, so it loses its simulacrum.  

In the final section of Jean Baudrillard, simulacra and simulation, the text discusses and debates the differences between the truth and a simulation of the truth. Simulacrum is ‘something that replaces reality with its representation’; an images that doesn’t have the quality’s of the original. In the text he describes a full screen, with the display of different products, brands and advertisements, this is a link to Plato’s cave. It is basically saying that advertising has lost its purpose, to inform and to communicate, because of the amount of times everything has been repeated.